Expired domains are often valuable in terms of the length of time they’ve been around for. When someone owns a domain name, they can decide whether they wish to renew it for a further period or let it go. If the domain expires (for whatever reason), it can go into an auction. Anyone can bid on a domain offered via auction – and if they offer the highest bid, they win the domain name.
It all sounds sensible enough, and mostly, it works fine. When a domain expires, it usually goes through a period that allows the original owner to repurchase it if desired. After a while, it is then put through for auction.
That’s what happened with two expired domain names that have now led to a lawsuit against GoDaddy. Butane.com was purchased by Prime Loyalty LLC via GoDaddy Auctions. Another plaintiff in the case, Crisby Studio AB, purchased Calor.com. UK company Calor Gas Limited previously owned both domains, and both went through the traditional expiration cycle with the GoDaddy registrar, 123-Reg.
However, some two months after those purchases were made via the auction process, GoDaddy took back the domain names. They said they’d been put up for auction in error. Given the two-month period between purchase and the clawback process, both businesses had begun to invest time and funds in the sites that would be put up on those domains. Both then decided to issue a lawsuit against GoDaddy.
While several claims were made as part of the lawsuit, a judge has allowed several to proceed. These include breach of contract and breach of the registration agreement in place. It remains to be seen how the lawsuit will proceed from here, and what the outcome might be.
Domain name owners should receive notification of the expiry of a domain name in ample time. Even if a domain name expires, as we’ve seen here, there is a period during which the original owner can still renew it if they want to. Only after this process has been completed will the domain name enter the auction process and become available for others to bid on.
It would appear that the usual process has been followed here, although we shall have to wait and see how the case turns out. One suspects that GoDaddy will need to explain how the error in auctioning the domain names occurred. If the usual process was followed, where and how could an error occur?
There is no word as yet on how long it might be before the case goes ahead. The key aspect here is whether there was a genuine error, and if so, whether that was still enough to warrant a clawback of the domain names. We’ll be watching closely to see the outcome of this case, since it could well be fascinating to see play out. One wonders who the eventual owners of those domain names might be, and what the outcome will be overall.
Thinking of buying or selling a domain? Revolut.co.uk® brokers domain sales and purchases, including anonymous stealth acquisitions.
Talk to us


